Back to glossary

-1HL

A method used by tournaments to determine winners of speaker awards. Using -1HL, the highest and lowest score is deleted before taking the average score used for final speaker placements

Speaker points are inherently subjective, and a single unusually harsh or unusually generous judge can distort a debater's tournament average. The -1HL method, short for "minus one high and one low," corrects for this by deleting each debater's single highest and single lowest speaker scores from preliminary rounds before calculating the average used for speaker awards. It works the same way scoring does in gymnastics or diving, where the extreme scores get thrown out so one outlier judge cannot decide the outcome. In practice, tournaments list their tiebreak formulas on their Tabroom invitation pages, and you will often see something like "Speaks -1HL, then total speaks." For debaters, the takeaway is reassuring: one rough round in front of a stingy judge will not sink your shot at a speaker award. For parents looking at results, -1HL explains why the average shown at the awards assembly does not match the simple average of every score on your student's ballots.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories