Back to glossary

Alternative/Alt

The offense of a kritik, that proposes a different way of thinking, acting, or being than the problematic assumptions or structures proposed by the opponents. The alternative is the solvency claim that explains why the new method resolves the harms of the opponent's hypothetical representations.

The alternative, or "alt," is the kritik's proposal, its answer to the question "then what should we do instead?" Rather than a policy action, it is usually a different way of thinking, being, or engaging: "reject the affirmative's security logic," "embrace an ethic of radical care," or "refuse the state's framing entirely." The alt is the kritik's solvency engine; it explains why voting negative actually resolves the harmful assumptions the kritik identifies rather than just complaining about them. Alt debates usually come down to solvency and clarity. Can rejecting one team's discourse in one high school round genuinely change anything? What does the world of the alternative concretely look like? Affirmatives press with permutations ("do both") and vagueness arguments, while kritik teams answer with framework arguments and links that explain why combining the two fails. When a debater asks in cross-ex about "the status of the alt," they are asking whether the negative can abandon it later in the round.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories