"Breaking new" means reading an argument publicly for the first time at a tournament, one that opponents cannot have scouted from the team's disclosure page, past round reports, or word of mouth. Teams deliberately save new cases, new advantages, or new off-case positions for high-stakes moments, and "they broke new in semis" is common circuit chatter.
The strategy trades surprise against polish. A brand-new position catches opponents without prepared answers, but it also has never survived contact with a real opponent, so hidden weaknesses may surface at the worst time. Disclosure norms interact with the choice too: on circuits where teams disclose previously read positions, breaking new is the legal way to stay unpredictable, though opponents may then demand disclosure of the new case once it has been read. Elimination rounds against well-scouted rivals are the classic moment to break new.