Back to glossary

Condo / Conditionality

A term used for progressive and Kritical debates that describes the type of alternative or status being read. Conditionality is a term that comes from policy debate, and traditionally describes negative burdens and the “conditions” to win the argument. There are three types of conditions: Unconditional, dispositional, conditional. An unconditional position means that it must be won and extended into the back half of the debate to win the argument (and typically the round). A conditional argument may not have to be won and extended into the backhalf to win the round. A dispositional argument will only be dropped if the opposing team does something during round.

Conditionality describes the terms under which a team, usually the negative, is allowed to abandon an advocacy it introduced. An unconditional position must be defended to the end of the round. A dispositional position can be dropped only under defined circumstances, classically if the opponents concede or straight-turn it. A conditional position can be kicked freely, letting the negative test the affirmative from multiple angles and keep only what is winning. The vocabulary comes from policy debate and travels with kritiks and counterplans into LD and public forum. Conditionality is one of debate's perennial fights. Its defenders argue it encourages broad testing of the affirmative and rewards flexible thinking; critics answer that debating three worlds at once skews the affirmative's time and strategy, which is the basis of "condo bad" theory shells. Asking "what's the status of your off-case positions?" in cross-examination pins opponents to an answer before they can quietly shift. Judges' tolerance varies enormously, so read paradigms before making conditionality the round's central issue.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories