Back to glossary

Conflicts

Conflicts are judges or debaters one cannot judge or be judged by due to experiences or relationships that may cause biased interests. Coaches who have worked for an insitution, for example, are considered conflicts against debaters of that institution.

Conflicts are registered relationships that prevent a judge from being assigned to particular debaters: having coached a student (currently or recently), being related to one, attending or working for the school, or judging a private coaching client. Judges list their conflicts on Tabroom, and the pairing software will not place them in those rounds. The system protects both fairness and the appearance of fairness. The norm is to conflict proactively and generously: if a reasonable observer might question whether you could judge someone neutrally, you conflict yourself, even when you are confident in your own objectivity. Coaches who move between programs are expected to conflict their former students for a season or more, and paid coaches must conflict everyone they work with. If you notice an unlisted conflict on a pairing, whether it involves you or an opponent, tell tab promptly and politely; catching it before the round is painless, while discovering it after a decision is ugly.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories