Evidence is the sourced material debaters quote to support their claims: academic studies, expert commentary, journalism, government data, and think-tank analysis, formatted into "cards" with tags and full citations. The NSDA's evidence rules govern its use, requiring accurate citation and prohibiting fabrication and distortion. Evidence is the load-bearing structure of most arguments in most formats.
The skill is not having evidence but evaluating and comparing it. A rough hierarchy, always context-dependent: peer-reviewed research and recognized experts, then quality journalism and institutional reports, then advocacy sources, with recency mattering enormously on fast-moving topics. Strong debaters compare evidence explicitly in round: qualifications, methodology, date, and how directly the source speaks to the exact claim. And sometimes the right answer to a bad card is not a better card but a sharp analytic that exposes what the card never actually says.