Back to glossary

High Phil/ Philosophical Kritiks

Debate arguments rooted in complex philisophical thesis such as moral philosophy that are generally more abstract. Unlike most kritiks, high philosophy tends to challenge meta-physical assumptions of debate rather than critique the resolution.

High phil, short for high philosophy, refers to arguments built from dense moral and metaphysical literature: Kantian ethics, phenomenology, contractarianism, and similar traditions. The style is most at home in Lincoln Douglas, where "phil debate" is a recognized genre. Unlike most kritiks, which critique power structures and the resolution's assumptions, high phil tends to defend or attack ethical theories themselves, and often challenges the meta-level assumptions of how debates should be evaluated. Engaging high phil without matching philosophical depth is possible if you attack structure: demand the syllogism be stated cleanly, contest its premises with intuitive counterexamples, and press hidden inferential leaps in cross-examination. Reading it yourself carries a duty of genuine understanding, because judges punish debaters who deploy philosophy they cannot explain when questioned. And in front of lay or flay judges, translation is everything; an airtight Kantian argument delivered in untranslated jargon persuades no one who has not already read Kant.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories