Back to glossary

Hold the Line

A phrase used by debaters to encourage judges to have standards for what kinds of arguments they take into account. This typically is used in the context of arguments that lack warrants or have been conceded.

"Hold the line" is a plea for the judge to enforce argumentative standards rather than granting leniency: refuse to credit claims that never had warrants, decline to rescue arguments abandoned for two speeches, and treat concessions as binding. It typically arrives in the backhalf attached to something specific: "they never answered our turn; hold the line on that concession." The phrase works because it names a real temptation in judging, filling gaps for a team whose argument was almost complete, and asks the judge to resist it. Its force depends entirely on specificity: paired with an exact concession or missing warrant it is a sharp weighing tool, while as a vague refrain it is noise. Judges' receptivity tracks their interventionism, with technical judges already inclined to hold lines and lay judges needing the standard explained in plain terms. Debaters also use the phrase between rounds as team encouragement to stay disciplined under pressure.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories