Back to glossary

Kicking a Judge

Deciding that a judge's philosophy/paradigm is too different to fully adapt to all judge's preferences on a panel. Debaters will then choose to adapt to the two other judge preferences on the panel.

On a three-judge elimination panel, the judges' preferences sometimes pull in opposite directions: imagine two experienced technical judges seated next to a parent volunteer. Since a team only needs two of the three ballots to advance, teams sometimes deliberately "kick" the incompatible judge. That means they stop trying to adapt to that judge's preferences entirely and debate the round squarely for the other two, accepting they will probably lose the kicked judge's ballot. Kicking a judge is a calculated gamble. It lets a team debate one coherent style instead of a watered-down compromise that persuades nobody, but it also surrenders a ballot that might have been winnable. Good teams read every paradigm on the panel before the round, count the likely ballots, and make the decision together, often with a coach's input. For parents who judge: if a round seems pitched over your head or under it, panel math may be why.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories