Back to glossary

Outweigh

A method that compares impacts of arguments on both sides, providing warrants as to why one team has more important impact than another using different mechanisms.

To outweigh is to win the impact comparison: establishing that your surviving arguments matter more than the opponent's under some named mechanism, whether magnitude, probability, timeframe, scope, or reversibility. It is the operative verb of impact calculus, and "we outweigh" is among the most common sentences in backhalf debate. The craft requirement is genuine comparison rather than parallel assertion: "their impact is speculative three-step economics; ours is documented and already beginning; prefer ours on probability" does work that "our impact is really important" does not. The prerequisite is a live argument, since outweighing with a dead impact is arithmetic on zero: extend first, then weigh. The reason this term matters so much: judges' reasons for decision routinely reduce to which team won the weighing, because close rounds almost never have one side winning every argument, and the comparison is what resolves the tie.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories