Back to glossary

Presumption Ballots

Ballot decisions made if a judge deems both sides have no offense. Presumption preferences vary between judges, for example, some judges prefer to presume for the first speaking team, while some presume for the negative team.

Presumption is the judge's tiebreaker when a round produces no offense for either side: if every argument washes or dies, someone must still win, and presumption names the default. Conventions vary, which is what makes it worth understanding: the traditional default presumes negative, on the logic that change requires justification, while some judges presume for the first-speaking team or against whichever side departed from the status quo, and paradigms occasionally state a preference. The practical guidance runs in two directions. As insurance: in genuinely washed rounds, a sentence establishing why presumption favors you ("if you believe nothing in this round, you default neg because...") can decide a ballot. As philosophy: never plan to win on presumption, because it is the outcome of last resort and judges reach for it reluctantly; a single cleanly extended piece of offense makes the entire question moot, which is the better strategy in every case.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories