Back to glossary

RFD

An acronym for "Reason For Decision". Judges submit their decision to tabroom and typically proceed to given an RDF what describes how they viewed the round and their reason for choosing the winning team. Judges also write written feedback and evaluation explanations on tabroom in the "RFD" section of each round's ballot.

The RFD, or Reason For Decision, is the judge's explanation of the ballot: which arguments decided the round and why. Depending on circuit, it arrives as an oral disclosure after the round, a written paragraph on the Tabroom ballot, or both. A good RFD names the decisive issue, explains the comparison the judge made, and lets both teams reconstruct exactly how the win happened. For debaters, RFDs are the activity's feedback engine, and harvesting them is a skill: flow oral RFDs like a speech, ask clarifying questions without relitigating, and review written ballots after the tournament looking for patterns, since "we keep losing on weighing" is a coaching plan disguised as a complaint. For parents judging: your RFD does not need jargon, and three honest sentences ("I voted con because the pro never answered the jobs argument, which felt most important by the end") are genuinely useful to competitors.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories