Scalar impacts are harms or benefits that scale continuously with the degree of the action: more emissions, more warming; more surveillance, more chilled speech; each increment of the cause produces an increment of the effect. They contrast with threshold or binary impacts, where the harm either triggers or does not, like a war that starts or a treaty that collapses.
The structure has real strategic properties. Scalar impacts survive mitigation gracefully: an opponent who proves your effect is half the claimed size has not eliminated it, and "even the reduced version outweighs" remains available, whereas threshold impacts die entirely when the triggering link breaks. Scalar claims also pair naturally with probability weighing, since every increment is near-certain even when the extreme scenario is not. Recognizing which structure an argument has, yours and theirs, tells you whether to attack the link entirely or fight over magnitude, and whether your own impact can absorb damage and keep functioning.