Back to glossary

Spikes

Arguments read in the opening constructive that preempt responsive arguments anticipated from the opposing team.

Spikes are preemptive arguments embedded in a case to defuse anticipated responses before they are ever made: a sentence in the constructive establishing why theory does not apply, why a common turn fails, or why a particular framework should be rejected if introduced. The genre ranges from transparent, legitimate preempts to deliberately buried traps designed to be overlooked and then sprung as "conceded" rounds later, the style associated with tricks-heavy circuit LD. Defending against spikes is reading hygiene: go through the opponent's doc line by line, ask in cross-examination what specific sentences do ("what is the function of underview three?"), and answer anything with argumentative content, however innocuous it looks, since the whole trap depends on your silence. Reading spikes yourself is judge-dependent territory, as many judges hold hidden arguments to elevated standards or refuse them entirely. The line worth teaching: visible preempts are strategy; buried spikes are gamesmanship with a reputational price.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories