Back to glossary

Voters

Standards or warrants for a judge to vote for a certain argument, typically used in theory debates.

Voters are the ballot-justification layer of an argument, most formally in theory shells, where "voters" names the final component explaining why a violation deserves the ballot itself, canonically fairness (skewed rounds cannot evaluate the better debating) and education (the practice degrades what debate teaches). The related everyday usage is "voting issues": the final-speech move of explicitly listing the reasons the judge votes for you. In theory debates, the voter layer carries its own sub-questions worth knowing: whether fairness and education are intrinsic goods or instrumental ones, and the remedy question, "drop the debater" (the violation loses the round) versus "drop the argument" (only the offending position dies). In general practice, the voters habit is simply excellent closing craft: "two voters in this round" hands the judge a prioritized, labeled decision, and teams that structure final speeches this way are doing the judge's organizational work for them, which is reliably rewarded. Leave the voters unstated and the judge chooses their own.

Search

Browse A–Z

Categories