Weighing is comparative impact analysis: the explicit argument for why your winning arguments matter more than theirs, conducted through named mechanisms like magnitude, probability, timeframe, scope, and reversibility. It is the difference between listing impacts and resolving a round, because close debates end with both teams winning something, and weighing is how the judge chooses between survivors without inventing the comparison themselves.
The craft requirements: weigh comparatively, not in parallel ("even if they win their economy impact, ours comes first because it happens sooner and causes theirs"); weigh early, in summary rather than debuting in final focus, so the comparison can be contested and won; and weigh live arguments, since a dead impact weighs nothing. When both teams weigh through different mechanisms, meta-weighing (arguing which mechanism should govern) breaks the tie. Judges' most frequent post-round complaint across every circuit is some version of "nobody weighed," which is another way of saying the team that weighs usually wins the rounds that could have gone either way.